Ice cube molds have evolved quite a bit over the years. The best ice cube trays are made of silicon to make removal of shaped cubes easier. Silicon molds also allow for more detailed ice cubes than you can get when using a plastic tray. When considering which ice tray to buy, consider how, when, and by whom the ice cubes will be used. This will help you determine which tray will meet your needs the best. We have included the best-rated ice cube trays we found online. Some have a classic design while others will make for the funniest or best-looking drinks.
13. Vitabliss Ice Mold Set
This ice molding set comes with two very different designs. The first is a four-count sphere mold and the second is a mustache-shaped mold. Because it is made of silicone, you can make flavored ice without worrying about transferring that flavor to the next round of ice you make. An unexpected combination, it is fun to mix the spheres and mustaches in a pitcher, especially if you use colored water to make the ice shapes. The mustache mold can also be used for flavored gelatin.
Note: This product is currently unavailable and we’re not sure whether or when it will be back in stock. If you are looking for something similar, check out these next two products instead of this set:
12. Arctic Chill Ice Ball Maker
This ice ball maker by Arctic Chill enables you to make up to 8 ice balls at a time. You can choose among trays that make 1-, 2-, and 2.5-inch ice balls. The trays are made of BPA-free, FDA-approved silicone, and the manufacturer claims the ice these trays make melts down very slowly. According to customer ratings and reviews, these are some of the best ice cube trays on the market
11. BargainRollBack Mustache Ice Cube Mold
This mustache ice cube mold by BargainRollBack is made of food-grade TPR (Thermal Plastic Rubber) and can make six slow-melting mustache-shaped ice cubes. The tray can also be used for jelly, pudding, chocolate, and other treats. If you’re looking for fun shapes, these are some of the best ice trays you could get.
10. Bella Amazing Silicone Jumbo Ice Tray
Larger ice cubes result in less drink dilution and a tastier beverage. This tray is 8.4 x 4.4 inches and makes eight ice cubes. These large cubes take longer to freeze. This tray is made of BPA-free, FDA-grade silicone. Ice cubes this big are well suited for mixed drinks or cocktails where it is important that the flavor remains undiluted. It is also good in breakfast drinks to prevent losing some of the juicy flavors that happens when smaller cubes melt faster, making them some of the best ice cube trays on the market.
9. Tovolo Leak-Free Silicone Sphere Ice Molds
These round ice cubes allow you to create beautiful drinks because of the two-part mold. You fill the mold from two holes in the top and leave it in the freezer. These 2.5 inch ice balls will take considerably longer than traditionally sized ice cubes. Like other large ice cubes, these are ideal for drinks that you do not want to be diluted. They are especially useful in large pitchers when serving a crowd, helping ensure the last drinks poured from the pitcher are as flavorful as the first. Adding fruit or colorful vegetables to the center of the mold also dresses up a plain water pitcher.
8. Excelity® MINI Silicone Ice Tray
You have two shape choices with this mini silicone ice tray: round and square cubes. Not only can you make small ice shapes, but you can also use these trays to bake mini cake or brownie bites as the maximum temperature this tray allows is 464 degrees Fahrenheit; however, you may need to adjust the cooking time accordingly. These are some of the best ice cube trays for people who like to chew their ice after finishing the drink.
7. Talisman Designs Ice Cube Tray
Whimsy is the inspiration behind these creative molds. There are three shapes to choose from – cat, dog, and man. These molds are less than five inches wide and about nine inches long. Each one serves double duty and can also be used as chocolate molds for party favors.
The various shapes are useful for a variety of themed parties. Children will like the animal shaped ice cubes. The ‘Perfect Man’ would be the best ice tray for a bridal shower or bachelorette party. Each of the four available designs is priced separately. The ‘Perfect Man’ mold comes in two colors: red and blue.
6. Stacking 50 Cavity Building Block Candy Mold
This ice tray creates 50 stacking, brick-shaped cubes and comes with a bonus six-figure mold. The set includes a 5 ml dropper that makes it easy to fill the tiny spaces. These brick shaped ice cubes are great for a kid’s or adult’s birthday party. The 50 pieces will stack so that you can build a variety of items with the square and rectangle bricks, apart from using them to chill beverages!
5. OMorc Premium Easy-Release Silicone Ice Cube Tray Pack
This 4-pack is one of the best ice cube tray sets as it also comes with spill-resistant lids. Smaller cubes like these will freeze faster than traditionally-sized cubes. Apart from its ice molding capabilities, this tray can be used to freeze homemade broth, homemade baby food, or even mold chocolates. Gelatin cubes are also a popular idea for silicone molds. In addition, these are also dishwasher-safe, which makes them some of the best ice cube trays for heavy use.
4. Candy Molds & Ice Cube Trays
This sphere ice cube trays make tiny ice spheres that each measure 0.67″ in diameter. The tray itself measures 9.44 x 2.83 x 0.78 inches. The silicone is rigid enough to hold its shape but flexible enough to make releasing the individual cubes easy. Small cubes are best for drinks that need to cool down quickly and for people who like to chew on ice. The cubes this size are also good for adding just the smallest amount of ice to your beverage which makes these some of the best ice trays on the market.
3. Peak Ice Works Large Cube Tray
Unlike many molds, this large tray comes with a cover to prevent freezer burn. Each of the four cubes is 2.25 inches. The entire tray is rather small, measuring only 6.4 x 6.4 x 2.4 inches. Do not let the small size fool you though, because the larger cubes will take longer to grow hard in the freezer. Trays like this make great gifts for friends who like their liquor cold but not diluted. The cover is unique and keeps the ice from smelling or tasting like other food items in the freezer.
2. Fred & Friends Silicone Smiley Face Ice Tray
Use this tray to make seven smile ice cubes that will make everyone grin. Each cube is about two inches in diameter and, due to the shallow size of each mold, these faces will freeze about as quickly as a traditional ice cube shape. These will be most useful for a child’s birthday party if you buy multiple molds or plan ahead and make lots of ice. These are, according to ratings and reviews from verified customers, the second best ice cube trays you could get this year.
1. Arrow 60-Cube Ice Tray Pack
This pack of 3 ice cube trays makes for the best ice cube trays currently on the market as it yields 180 slow-melting bullet-shaped ice cubes in a go. Although it’s not made of silicone, the trays are flexible enough to get the cubes out in one piece, yet rigid enough not to spill the water on your way to the freezer.
Silicone makes the best ice cube tray material. I find that slow melting ice is important when you do not want to sacrifice the flavor or strength of a drink. It was hard to decide which one is the best ice cube tray but I choose the Vitabliss round ice mold. It has double the capacity and round ice will not chip off in my glass. The two-part construction makes it possible to add fresh fruit to my ice for both flavor and color.