Top 10 Undercounter Ice Maker Reviews

Whether you're entertaining friends or filling coolers for camping, there are times you will need ice. It's costly and inconvenient to run to the store every time the need arises. Consider installing an under counter ice maker for a continuous supply of ice. It will provide crystal-clear, restaurant-quality ice for all your needs. To take the guesswork out of your purchase, we have reviewed the top under counter ice makers.

Under Counter Ice Maker FAQ

What Is An Under Counter Ice Maker?

 What Does An Under Counter Ice Maker Do?

How Does An Under Counter Ice Maker Work?

Where Can You Buy An Under Counter Ice Maker?

How We Reviewed

Products were reviewed based on the following parameters: Features, Pros & Cons, Price, Where to Buy, and Warranty. 

glasses of carbonated drinks full of  ice

Overall Price Range of This Product  

The price of under counter ice makers varies widely. The products we reviewed in this article range from $300 to $1,840. The more expensive units offer higher production rates and storage capacity. Less expensive units just insulate the storage bins but they aren't freezers, so ice must be removed from them and stored in a freezer or it will melt.

What We Reviewed

  • Sunpentown IM-150US
  • Scotsman CU50GA-1A
  • U-Line BI95B
  • Whynter UIM-155
  • Mosel 15"
  • Edgestar IB 120SS
  • Orien FS-55IM
  • SPT IM-600US
  • Koldfront KIM450BL
  • Manitowoc UD-0140A NEO
fridge


Features

This under counter ice maker features a stylish stainless steel door and a black cabinet. The unit has an auto-shutoff to stop ice production when the ice bin is full. It makes up to 12 pounds of ice daily. The storage bin will hold up to six pounds of ice. There is a manual defrost feature for maintenance and cleaning.

Pros

Makes up to 12 pounds of ice a day


Elegant stainless steel


Manual defrost

Cons

Fans are loud


Trapped ice can impede ice production


Poor customer service

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.


Warranty

This product carries a one-year warranty from the manufacturer.


fridge

 

Features

This under counter ice maker is designed for commercial applications. It requires a floor drain directly under it for its gravity draining of condensate. It is approved for outdoor use. This unit produces up to 65 pounds of crystal-clear, slow-melting, gourmet ice. The storage bin will hold up to 26 pounds of ice. It is available with a built-in drain pump for flexibility in installation.

Pros

Approved for outdoor use


Commercial grade


Makes 65 pounds of ice a day

Cons

Cubes drop noisily into the storage bin


Develops mold inside 


Difficult to clean

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$$$.


Warranty

This product carries a one-year limited warranty from the manufacturer.


fridge


Features

This under counter ice maker produces up to 23 pounds of ice a day, and it uses less than three gallons of water to do so. It makes crescent-shaped cubes with minimal electricity. It is easy and economical to install. This high-quality, under counter ice maker is ADA compliant and made in the USA.

Pros

Produces up to 23 pounds of ice a day  


No drain required


Made in the USA

Cons

Requires the additional purchase of an installation kit


Makes large cubes

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$$$.


Warranty

No warranty information is available for this product. Reviewers reported there was no warranty from the manufacturer or reseller.



fridge

 

Features

This ice maker can be either built-in under the counter or installed as a freestanding unit. It does not require a drain. The unit will make 12 pounds of ice in 24 hours. It makes crescent-shaped cubes. The ice maker features an elegant stainless steel door and a black cabinet that will complement your kitchen or bar. It includes a 6 pound storage bin and a plastic ice scoop. The auto-shutoff feature of the unit stops it from producing further ice when the storage bin is full. It uses a high-efficiency compressor free of CFCs.

Pros

Front-venting allows for built-in or freestanding installation


CFC free high-efficiency compressor


No drain required

Cons

Requires frequent defrosting


Makes bullet ice, not cubes

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.


Warranty

This product carries a one-year limited warranty from the manufacturer.


fridge


Features

This under counter ice maker produces up to 32 pounds of ice in 24 hours. The unit can produce three different sizes of ice cubes. It features a drain pump, so it does not need a floor drain, and the storage bin will hold up to 20 pounds of crystal-clear ice. The storage bin is removable for easy ice disposal and cleaning. The Mosel 15" has an auto-off feature to prevent overfilling of the storage bin. It must be manually defrosted.

Pros

Produces up to 32 pounds of ice in 24 hours


Doesn't require a floor drain


Makes crystal-clear ice

Cons

Ice in the storage bin melts


Unit operates loudly

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$.

Warranty

This product carries a two-year limited warranty from the manufacturer.


fridge


Features

This ice maker is front-venting so both built-in and freestanding installations are possible. It meets ADA height compliance. The door is reversible for either left or right opening. The unit features auto-shutoff when the storage bin reaches capacity. It produces up to 12 pounds of crescent-shaped "cubes" per day. The storage bin will hold up to six pounds of ice and will keep it frozen so a floor drain is not needed. A stainless steel door and black body will complement your decor. An ice scoop is included.

Pros

Unit can be built-in or freestanding 


Auto-shutoff feature


No floor drain required

Cons

Requires frequent manual defrosting


Requires frequent manual defrosting

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $.


Warranty

No warranty information is available for this product. 


fridge


Features

This ice maker features front-venting for use under the counter or as a freestanding unit. It is capable of making up to 44 pounds of ice cubes in 24 hours. A removable storage bin can hold up to 25 pounds of cubes. The stainless steel door is reversible for left or right opening and features a full-length handle. The unit uses a gravity drain and requires either a floor drain or installation of an optional condensate pump. The air-cooled condenser is CFC free. Automatic overflow protection prevents the storage bin from overfilling.

Pros

Makes up to 44 pounds of ice in 24 hours  


Reversible stainless steel door


CFC free condenser

Cons

Noisy operation


Cubes don't easily break apart

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$$$.


Warranty

No warranty information is available for this product. 


fridge


Features

This ice maker features front-facing ventilation for use under the counter or as a freestanding unit. It makes up to 50 pounds of restaurant-quality cubes in 24 hours. The removable storage bin holds up to 25 pounds of ice. The stainless steel door is reversible for left or right opening and features a full-length handle. Use of a water filter is highly recommended to prevent buildup of lime scale and increase the unit's longevity. The unit has an auto-shutoff feature to prevent overfilling of the storage bin.


This unit requires installation by a licensed plumber. The storage bin is insulated, but it does not function as a freezer; to preserve ice for long periods, cubes must be moved to a freezer.

Pros

Produces up to 50 pounds of ice daily 


Can be built-in or used freestanding


Reversible stainless steel door for left or right opening

Cons

Must be installed by a licensed plumber


Does not keep the ice frozen in the storage bin


Requires a water filter

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$$$.


Warranty

This product carries a limited one-year warranty from the manufacturer.


fridge


Features

This ice maker produces up to 45 pounds of ice daily. The unit vents to its front, allowing it to be built-in or used freestanding. Simple computer controls make ice-making easy. The removable storage bin will hold up to 25 pounds of crystal-clear, restaurant-quality ice cubes. It has adjustable leveling legs to fit perfectly in its designated space.


The manufacturer strongly recommends purchasing the water filter accessory to protect the unit from a buildup of lime scale, which can affect the water pump's efficiency and can cause the ice to have bad odors and flavors. The unit requires installation by a licensed plumber. It will need to be installed over a floor drain or fitted with an optional condensate pump. The unit is well-insulated, but it is not a freezer and stored ice will eventually melt if not moved to a freezer.

Pros

Produces 45 pounds of ice daily  

Computer controlled


Adjustable leveling legs

Cons

Requires installation by a licensed plumber


Requires a floor drain or optional condensate pump


Bin is not a freezer

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$.


Warranty

No warranty information is available for this product.


fridge

Edit your caption text here

Features

This under counter ice maker produces an impressive 132 pounds of ice daily. The storage bin will hold 90 pounds of cubes in any of the three sizes it can produce. This unit features a slanted front and easy-glide door. The bin slides forward for easy maintenance. It features Alphasan, a coating molded into key components, which reduces bacteria, mildew, mold and yeast growth. It has pop-out air filters.

Pros

Makes 132 pounds of ice daily   


Alphasan reduces mold and mildew growth


Pop-out filters

Cons

Ice comes out in sheets and needs to be broken apart


Loud operation

Price

This product can be found on Amazon for around $$$$.

Warranty

No warranty information is available for this product.


The Verdict

For commercial application, we feel the best under counter ice maker is the Manitowoc UD-0140A NEO. It produces an impressive 132 pounds of ice in 24 hours and has superior mold and mildew protection. If you're not looking for such huge quantities of daily ice production though, and just want a good ice maker for your man cave, tiki bar or kitchen, we recommend the Edgestar IB120SS. Its versatile design allows it to be built-in or freestanding, and no drain is required since stored ice is kept frozen. Its stylish stainless steel door opens to the left or right and will complement any decor. Its daily production of 12 pounds of ice is adequate for a party or large family gathering. These are great machines that will keep you in ice for years.

(Visited 48 times, 1 visits today)

Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.